Yves Saint Laurent Dessin Du Regard Waterproof Waterproof Eye Pencil

In the last 10 years, this pencil has been the best one I've had. It doesn't smudge even when my eyes water. It's neither greasy nor dry - just what I need.

Unfortunately, it smudges :(

The pencil itself is soft, which allows for easy blending, but the tip is quite thick, which is not very convenient.

The makeup looks good for about 3 hours, but then it starts to run and the lines look messy.

The pencil draws precise lines for winged eyeliner and doesn't smudge. I accidentally found a pencil sharpener in the box. As a bonus, they also included their branded mascara as part of a promotion. Thank you for the pleasant experience.

Whoever claims that this eyeliner smudges clearly has not seen it! This eyeliner is amazing! It is soft and glides easily on the eyelid. The black color is rich and intense, resulting in beautiful eyeliner looks. It is definitely worth the money. I highly recommend it!

Unfortunately, this product smudges heavily, smears, and leaves imprints. I'm disappointed.

Before purchasing, I asked the consultant if the pencil sharpener was included in the set (since there was no information about it in the description, but many girls mentioned in their reviews that it comes with the pencil). The consultant replied that the set does not include a sharpener. Despite this, I still decided to buy this pencil. Today, I received the pencil, and it turns out that there is indeed a branded sharpener in the set, which is in a box with the pencil. I cannot say anything about the quality of the pencil itself yet, as I have not had a chance to try it. I bought it for filling in the inner eyelid and I really hope it will be suitable!

I was given this amazing pencil as a gift. It was love at first sight. The quality is exceptional. It applies smoothly and precisely! In the evening, I tried to smudge it with my hand, but it didn't smear at all! I won't buy another one anymore! The makeup stays on all day, even though I applied it on my eyelids without a primer under the eyeshadow.

Gift from my husband, such a waste of money. The pencil is terrible. It leaves black streaks and I constantly have to touch up my makeup to remove the black circles, especially around the corner of my eyes. I have to redraw where it smudges, approximately every 30 minutes. The lead is thick, so it takes some getting used to in order to achieve a smooth line.

I agree. A few hours of use and you'll have the panda effect guaranteed.
I never thought I would write such a review about my favorite brand, but using this pencil is inconvenient - the lead is too thick, it smudges heavily. Even when you try to blend it with a brush, you still end up looking like a cabaret artist.

This is the best pencil out of all that I have tried. It applies easily, very long-lasting, and passed the rain test. I am extremely satisfied with it.