Maybelline New York Lasting Drama 24h Carbon Matte Eyeliner Eyeliner

I am purchasing my second pencil of a different color from this series. It applies smoothly and stays in place. The first pencil does become a little drier over time, but it doesn't hinder me from making normal lines. I am satisfied with this purchase.

The pencil is worthless. Its only advantage is the color (I have lapis navy). It is hard, dry, crumbles when applied, impossible to draw a line, and there is no question of blending. The quality is terrible. The makeup service, as always, is at an excellent level.

Terrible pencil. I purchased the shade lapis navy. It is hard, smudges on the eyelid, and is difficult to blend. I bought it for the waterline, but it not only does not stay in place, it doesn't even draw. Money wasted.

The pencil is long-lasting, but I didn't like its texture - it feels like hard clay. When applying, the lead slips, smudges, and crumbles. Moreover, with time, the situation with crumbling worsens, as if the pencil is drying out.

The pencil is long-lasting, but throughout the day, it does smudge and smear a bit. However, it's not a big issue!

Great pencil!
Convenient format. Pleasant color. It holds well and doesn't smudge. I am completely satisfied with the purchase.