Vivienne Sabo Charbon Liquid Eyeliner

I am writing a review after using the entire bottle.
The eyeliner lasted a long time, I used it every 1-2 days for about a year. It is long-lasting, doesn't smudge, and only starts to crack and crumble towards the end of the day.
However, there is one drawback that makes me hesitant to repurchase it now - occasionally, it irritates my eyelids after application. Therefore, I do not recommend it.

Perhaps, for this price, you can learn to live with it. However, there is a feeling of tightness. The brush is too thick and not very suitable for precise lines.

I mostly liked the eyeliner. In the first few days, I did feel a slight tightness, but it quickly went away. Now I apply it and everything is normal.

The eyeliner is great. The delivery was fast. The quality is superb. The brush is very good. Thanks to the courier.

This eyeliner is my love. The brush is thin and dense, making it very convenient to draw precise lines. It doesn't smudge or flake off, and it has a matte finish.

I am very satisfied with this eyeliner! It stays perfectly in place all day long, even though I have oily skin.

The eyeliner is simply disappointing. It has no lasting power at all. If your eye happens to tear up, it smudges immediately. You constantly have to touch it up throughout the day.
I used it for a week and ended up throwing it away. It was just a waste of money.

It's an eyesore, it makes you go bald, it's not a brush, it's just a stick - no words, just emotions. Absolutely, I will never order it again.

I ordered this product based on good reviews and now I am confused. The eyeliner has a good consistency, applies smoothly, and has a convenient handle and brush for drawing. I bought it and I'm happy!
However...
On the second day of use, I had to touch up my eyes three times because the line kept smudging and it caused a burning sensation when applied. When it started to slightly burn my eyelid again on the third day, I immediately removed and threw it away to avoid causing harm to my eye.

I liked it, but it takes some getting used to the brush, it holds well, and you can create fine lines with it.

Rich black color. It is not possible to layer it, as it cracks and flakes over time.

My favorite eyeliner, I bought it on recommendation a few years ago and I still only buy this one.

This eyeliner is amazing, my favorite! It took me a while to get used to the very stiff applicator, BUT in the end, I believe that this type of applicator is actually a big plus.

I didn't buy it here, but the eyeliner is very watery. It holds on decently, but you need to apply it in two layers.

THE BEST MASCARA I'VE EVER USED IN MY ENTIRE LIFE!

This is my favorite eyeliner. It is very long-lasting, vibrant, and easy to apply.

I have been using this eyeliner for probably two years now. It stays on well throughout the day. By the end, I can only touch up the tips of my winged liner. The only thing I don't like (maybe it's just me) is that even when I apply powder under the eyeliner, it still shines after a couple of hours. I would prefer the wings to be matte all day. What's great is that if water gets on the wings, they don't smudge or run, they stay put (as long as you don't rub them and let them dry on their own, of course).

Uneven when applied, so a second layer is necessary. There is a burning sensation until it dries, but then it's fine. The positives are that it stays on well and doesn't crumble.

I don't know what girls used before buying this "miracle" to write so many positive reviews. But for me, this eyeliner is simply horrible. It dries faster than you can finish applying it and doesn't go on evenly. It's inconsistent. Overall, I absolutely disliked it. I bought another one and threw this one away without any regrets.

The eyeliner is just like any other eyeliner. The brush dries too quickly when applying, so you have to constantly dip it back into the bottle. It goes on smoothly and stays on well. The color is a rich, intense black.

The formula itself is really good, with a rich black color that dries perfectly matte. However, the brush is something else. It's too stiff, which would be a plus if it wasn't so huge and thick :(( It's impossible to draw thin lines with it, unless you use a brush from another product. Other than that, the formula of the eyeliner is actually very good.

It seems to be good, but it burns the eyelid afterwards... I even feel like it slightly swells.

This eyeliner is truly MATTE. It stays on very well and applies neatly.

I really liked the eyeliner. The brush is firm, which is more convenient for me than a soft one. It is easier to apply a precise line, like with a pencil. The color is sharp and black. I recommend it!

Great eyeliner, long-lasting, convenient brush. I am satisfied with it.

The brush turned out to be very inconvenient for me; it was difficult to apply a proper winged eyeliner.

I believe that for this price, it is an excellent eyeliner. The brush is actually quite stiff, but if you apply winged eyeliner every day, you get used to it pretty quickly. Of course, if you prefer thinner lines, it would be better to choose an eyeliner with a softer brush. Overall, I like this eyeliner.

After reading the reviews, I decided to give it a try and unfortunately, I was disappointed. The brush is indeed very stiff, and when I applied it, it even made my eyelid burn. Well, at least for me, I have sensitive skin. When I applied a thick layer, it sometimes cracked and by the evening, it would start to flake a little. If I applied it with a thinner layer, the color looked more gray than black.

For its price, this eyeliner is simply perfect. It applies easily, stays in place well, and doesn't smudge or run.

Just perfect, this brush is convenient. I actually liked it, despite many people saying it's stiff and impractical, I disagree. The eyeliner is meant for those who like to cry and always stay at their best. It has survived tears (well, as long as you don't rub your eyes, any long-lasting makeup will come off) and rainstorms and sleep.

I have been using this product for about 3 years now. It is fabulous. Not only does it have a firm brush that allows me to create precise and thin lines, but it also becomes matte after some time, making it look even more expensive.

I ordered this eyeliner based on the recommendation of a makeup artist. It is good, long-lasting, and has a rich black color. I personally prefer a solid brush! However, there is a big but! I waited for over a week for my order, even though I had already paid for it. I ended up canceling two orders altogether because they never managed to fulfill my order, as they informed me over the phone. It is impossible to get through to their customer hotline. I did not expect to encounter such problems. I am not satisfied with their service. After lengthy email exchanges and complaints, I was finally contacted by four representatives from the website. It takes a lot of effort to get them to send out the paid order.

Perfect eyeliner! It is very easy to apply, has a matte color, and stays on well throughout the day. I believe it will now become my favorite.

Please note that the brush is stiff, which didn't work for me as it makes it difficult to apply and create eyeliner. However, the quality is superb! I simply prefer a softer brush.

The eyeliner is excellent - it's long-lasting, matte, and doesn't have any shine. It stays on all day, so I highly recommend it.

The eyeliner is quite good. I always look for matte eyeliners specifically, but for some reason, there are very few of them. This one is 100% matte, which I really like. The applicator is a bit inconvenient, but I think it just takes getting used to. It has average lasting power, I would prefer something better...

The eyeliner is pretty good. The brush is convenient for me, and it has a matte finish. However, I have to touch it up a bit throughout the day, especially in the inner corner of the eye, as it tends to flake off slightly. But it's definitely worth the price.

Great eyeliner. It is pigmented, doesn't smudge, and has a convenient brush. I highly recommend it.

I use it every day. I apply it in the morning and it stays in place all day without smudging or running.

It tends to crumble quite quickly by the evening and indeed irritates the eyes upon application. It requires reapplication throughout the day. However, the brush is not bad.

Intensely black, with a matte finish, this product is long-lasting - it can handle anything. I have been using it exclusively for 8 years now. The only downside is that the felt brush does not allow for precise lines. So, when I want thin lines, I use a different brush, but when I want thicker ones, I rely on the original one. It dries quickly. I highly recommend it.

I understand that the shelf life is 30 months, but the manufacturing date of 09.2017 is somewhat concerning.

I cannot say that this is the best eyeliner I have tried, but for its price, it is excellent.

This product is very disappointing! It doesn't work at all, and it crumbles. Maybe it's defective. I will go back to using Artdeco or Chanel instead.

The eyeliner met my expectations and was absolutely perfect! It lasts wonderfully throughout the entire day, with easy application and most importantly, it doesn't irritate the sensitive eye area. I highly recommend it.

I used to buy my favorite eyeliner from a different place, but this time I decided to order it from your website. Unfortunately, I received the product today with a manufacturing date of 05.2017. It is very disappointing to receive a product that is almost expired, especially since it is used near the eyes. As a loyal customer of yours, I am saddened by the fact that I can no longer fully trust your store when ordering products from certain categories.

A very worthy eyeliner for its price. It doesn't crumble and lasts a long time.

I received it today. The expiration date is until 11.19 (if we trust the sticker), but that smell! It has a dampness smell with some added chemicals. Girls who have used it, can you please tell me how it should normally smell? I don't know about other indicators because I'm afraid to try it.

The eyeliner is terrible, it applies poorly and doesn't stay on my eyes for more than an hour. Additionally, be aware that I received an eyeliner with a short expiration date (8 months left), so it's better to clarify before placing an order.

Great eyeliner. There is one downside, though. It absolutely cannot withstand any moisture, even if your eyes water just from the wind or you get lightly caught in the rain/snow - within a couple of seconds, it will run all over your face.

Yes, the eyeliner is not advertised as waterproof, so I won't deduct points for that, as it is indeed really good. It lasts all day, doesn't smudge, has a matte finish, and is highly pigmented.