Seventeen Proliner Liquid Eyeliner

I have found this eyeliner to be very good. I was looking for a replacement for the smudgy Vivienne Sabo one and I am satisfied with this one. It applies easily, doesn't smudge, and the color is a deep black. It stays on throughout the day.

I did not like it. The eyeliner flakes off and does not stay on the lashes for long.

Good eyeliner. It's very convenient to use, especially for those with shaky hands. It lasts a long time and the eyeliner in the tube doesn't dry out until it's fully used.
The claim that it doesn't smudge on the upper eyelid is not true. The eyeliner is not waterproof, so it smudges and leaves marks easily.

This eyeliner is absolutely not long-lasting, it smudges even with a finger and instantly starts running with the slightest amount of moisture. It's a complete disappointment and definitely not worth the money. The only positive aspect is that it's easy to draw precise lines with the firm brush. I have normal skin with slightly droopy eyelids, and this eyeliner leaves imprints after approximately one to one and a half hours.

Matte, intense black, long-lasting and easy to remove with makeup remover. However, it feels unusual to apply with a soft, fine brush as it is quite firm.

One of the best eyeliners I have ever used! This eyeliner has a matte finish and comes with a small, firm brush that makes application very easy. As a result, it does not crack, smudge, or run throughout the day. It also easily washes off with micellar water.

I am very satisfied with this excellent eyeliner!

The eyeliner is quite long-lasting and has a rich black color. It doesn't smudge or smear throughout the day. One downside is the stiff brush. I didn't consider it when ordering, and it's not convenient to use.

This is a great matte eyeliner with a firm brush. It dries quickly and does not smudge!

This is an excellent matte eyeliner with a felt tip applicator. It does not smudge and lasts for a long time.