Deborah Extra Eye Pencil Cosmetic Eye Pencil

This is the best eyeliner pencil. The texture is wonderful and it applies smoothly. It is easy to create nice winged lines with it. It lasts all day without smudging or transferring onto the skin. The color 02 is a rich dark blue, almost black, and it looks great!

Great texture. Perfect for oily eyelids, just what I needed (doesn't smudge).

As an eyeliner for the upper eyelid, it's decent - the line stays put, it's easy to apply and blend. However, it's definitely not a waterproof pencil as advertised! This is the main disappointment because I bought it for the inner line on the lower eyelid. It's not suitable for that purpose - it doesn't draw smoothly and smudges immediately.