Vivienne Sabo Waterproof Liquid Eyeliner Charbon Waterproof Eyeliner

I absolutely did not like it. Moreover, it behaved differently on my eyes and on my hand. Firstly, the brush was stiff, making it feel like drawing with a log, and it was also thick. Secondly, the color was not black, but rather a translucent gray-black, something like that. The color itself was not intensely black, it even felt diluted with water. I drew some eyeliner at home as a test, and after a couple of hours, it started to crumble on my eyelid. Although the test strip on my hand remained unchanged throughout the night.

This waterproof eyeliner is fantastic. The winged lines stayed on my eyes from 8 in the morning until 11 at night without any additional touch-ups (considering it was drizzling rain outside all day). So, I don't understand those people who write in reviews something like "I can't wash it off" or "I can't fix the wing with a cotton swab" - this eyeliner is wa-ter-proof. It can be removed either with a special eye makeup remover, micellar water, or makeup remover gel, but definitely not just water.

Great eyeliner, I constantly buy it here. It creates a perfect line and applies smoothly. If something goes wrong, it is easy to remove the line without smudging it. It stays on well until you remove it. Of course, since it is waterproof, you need to use special products to remove it. Someone mentioned that the tip is stiff, but after a day or two of use, it works perfectly. I am satisfied!

Terrible eyeliner. The brush is not convenient to use. The line is not clear and has gaps, so you have to go over it again (after which it starts to crack. Not worth the money. I will never buy this again. And also, the eyeliner irritates the eyes terribly.

The eyeliner is absolutely amazing, with a convenient brush that doesn't smudge. It lasted the whole day and the winged lines looked perfect. I also want to express my gratitude for the fast delivery by the courier.

It cracks and flakes off the skin in pieces, requiring frequent touch-ups and reapplication.

I used to use a marker eyeliner before. It was more convenient, but you can quickly get the hang of this brush as well. The lines it creates are highly pigmented and black. You can make both thin and thick lines. The eyeliner does not smudge, leave any marks, or flake off! Removing it is really difficult (only with special products). However, I don't consider this a drawback because the eyeliner stays perfectly on my eyelids throughout the day, even in rain or heat.

I don't like it. It gets stuck in the tiniest folds, which makes it look untidy.

The eyeliner is excellent. I've learned to create perfect winged lines with this brush in just 2 days. The main advantage of this eyeliner is that it doesn't smudge. I've slept with my winged lines on and woke up with them looking just as good as before I went to bed.

I resisted for a long time to "cheat" on my favorite eyeliner from another brand. But I bought this one and I don't regret it! It lasts 9 out of 10, has a rich charcoal color, applies smoothly, and doesn't smudge. It even survived rain and wind after a long workday.

I didn't buy it here, but I would like to leave a review. This product really makes my eyes burn.

The eyeliner is truly waterproof and does not smudge on the eyelid. It has a 5-star durability rating. The only thing worth changing for the manufacturer is the brush (it's a bit short, so you have to draw the line several times, which takes a bit of time). However, the durability outweighs this drawback. And as always, Make Up is excellent. P.S. The eyeliner in the photo lasted for 8 hours.

The eyeliner is long-lasting and not easily removed with water, but can be easily removed with micellar water. It does not smudge on the lower eyelid (which was a problem for me before). It did not run or fade in the rain. Overall, it is a good eyeliner, and I liked it!

I have been using this eyeliner for several years now and I only buy this one. I have oily skin and droopy eyelids, and usually eyeliners do not pass the test even during the swatch. So here it is. This eyeliner is super long-lasting, intensely black, and lasts a long time. Even if it's extreme: we ran around with it for a day, got caught in the rain, rubbed it with our hands, it will come off in pieces, not smudging embarrassingly. The only downside is that the brush at the end is stiff and blunt, so I do not recommend it for fans of ultra-thin lines. It is impossible to remove without the help of special products, which is definitely a plus for me. I definitely recommend this product!

The makeup this time was especially pleasing: everything in the large package was extremely fresh, excellently packaged, and arrived within a few hours. Thank you!

I purchased this amazing eyeliner from the NL brand for only 400 hryvnias. After several years, I decided to take a budget option and it turned out to be simply fantastic. It is extremely long-lasting. The only thing is that the brush is a bit stiff, so you might need to get used to it or use a different one. I highly recommend this product, ladies! With the wet snow coming soon, this eyeliner will stay in place.

Great eyeliner! I have tried many and for its price, this one is superb! It lasts a long time, I would rate it 5 out of 5 for its staying power. Ladies, I highly recommend it.

I didn't like it, it sheds and feels sticky. There's nothing special about it. I had a similar non-waterproof one before and I was satisfied with it. I bought it because of some discount, but I don't recommend it.

The eyeliner is indeed waterproof! However, the brush is somewhat strange as it picks up more product with its flat side rather than the tip.

I did not like the eyeliner at all. It smudges, sticks, clumps, and the brush scratches. The only good thing about it is the intense black color. As for the store, it is as great as always.

I ordered it for the first time and I really liked the eyeliner. Thank you.

I don't understand the negative reviews, I really liked this eyeliner. Please note that it does not have a soft brush. For those who are used to that, of course, it will be uncomfortable. You need to pay attention to what you are buying. The brush is firm and felt, it is very convenient for me to draw precise and neat lines. It doesn't smudge and dries quickly. It is easy to remove with hydrophilic oil.

This is simply a terrible disaster, not an eyeliner. Moreover, the formula of the eyeliner itself is quite good, long-lasting, and comes off easily with a film. But oh my, this brush of yours... The manufacturer should focus on producing skewers for barbecue instead of eyeliner. While you attempt to create a winged look, you will end up poking your own eye out with this digging stick. I strongly advise against it, unless you want to poke your enemy's eye out.

This is a very good and long-lasting eyeliner with a convenient brush.