Physicians Formula Eye Booster Gel Eyeliner Trio Black (eyeliner/3*0.37g) Waterproof Gel Eyeliner Set with 3 Finish

I really liked all three. They are soft, easy to apply, and color well between the lashes. They do smudge a bit, but I have that problem with all products, so compared to other pencils, they are simply great. They are suitable for sensitive eyes, and I even apply them on my waterline without any discomfort or irritation. The glitter in one of the pencils is hardly noticeable and not bright.

I really liked these pencils both as an eyeliner and for the waterline, as well as using them as a black base! For the base, it's better to apply them on a brush first and then blend them on the eyelid, because if you apply the pencil directly, it sets and becomes almost impossible to blend. Specifically on the eye, I don't see any difference between all three, except for the shimmery one - it has tiny sparkles. Excellent quality for the price. I swatched them by smudging them with my finger so that the flexibility of each shade was visible. I will probably purchase a set of brown ones as well.