Arcancil Paris Starliner Waterproof Eye Pencil

I would like to add to my review. In addition to all the listed drawbacks, the pencil started to crumble and fall apart horribly (even though I use a good base). And this happened within the normal expiration date. This means that the manufacturer miscalculated somewhere and produced a very low-quality product. It's a complete disappointment.

The pencil is average. Firstly, it draws semi-transparently, requiring multiple strokes. Secondly, it is very soft, resulting in thick lines. Additionally, the lead is loose. It stays well on the eyelid, but cannot be applied to the mucous membrane. It is made in Germany.
I have the color Figue doree, it is a nice shade with a slight shimmer. I did not buy it here.

This is an excellent pencil, very smooth.

I really liked the pencil! However, I'm sorry to say that there is only half a year left until the expiration date! I am shocked!

I bought the color amethyst, and the pencil is soft. It is marketed as waterproof, but in my case, it doesn't seem to be. The color is beautiful, with a slight pearlescent finish.

I use it as an eyeliner. It's the perfect balance - not dry, not greasy. It doesn't smudge (at least during the winter period). It's very convenient that it has a retractable and thin tip that doesn't need sharpening.

Strange pencil. At first, I was disappointed because I wanted a brown color, but it was much lighter in the picture. However, it actually came even darker than I have from Artdeco (Deep Brown). But when I tried it on my eyelids, it was actually quite good! Soft. Maybe a bit too soft in some cases, but if you don't press too hard with the pencil, the lines are drawn very easily. That's a plus. However, when it's not perfectly sharp and if you press a little too hard - it comes out rough and not beautiful. That's a minus. It also doesn't wash off easily. Although, I don't have a specialized waterproof remover. Maybe that's why. It's difficult to remove from the lash line, but very easy from everywhere else. That's how this pencil is...

The pencil is good, I got the shade 542 gold. It applies and stays well all day! The only downside, and this is not the first time, is that its expiration date is until March 2016. I'm not sure if I'll use it up that quickly. I don't like that no one warns about this in advance. It was the same with the hair mask.... It would be better if they immediately said if the product has a short expiration date left. Everyone uses it differently, someone can use it up in a month.... Girls, I beg you, please warn about expiration dates!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

The pencil is excellent, I have been using it for several years. It is very durable, does not cause irritation, and does not leave marks where it is not needed. The only downside is that it does not come in black. Overall, I am glad that this brand's cosmetics are now available in makeup stores, as I used to have to run around looking for them in cosmetics shops.