Artdeco Soft Eye Liner Waterproof Waterproof Eye Pencil

I bought the blue one and it looks great, both in terms of color and overall quality. However, I recently purchased the black one and I regret it. I thought it was waterproof, but it smudges and fades within 2 hours, especially when I apply it on my eyelids as eyeliner. It's disappointing because it's not a cheap product, and I'm curious why the blue one holds up well while the black one is completely ineffective.

Very dry, difficult to use. Does not stain or smudge on the inner eyelid. Used only for more precise lines.

"This pencil is excellent, I highly recommend it. It is quite soft."

Great pencil. I got the color 95 - graphite. It looks nice and applies easily.

It's not quite what I expected. The product tends to smudge on my eyelids, although the color is pleasant.

I really liked this pencil. It applies smoothly and softly, and it is also waterproof. As a result, it can be a bit challenging to remove with micellar water.

I really liked the pencil. The shade is number 11, a beautiful rich color. It applies smoothly, without smudging or running, and stays on well all day, even on my oily eyelids. It also comes off easily.

The pencil is terrible. I bought it a long time ago, but I still struggle to use it in any way. I got the black one, and it sharpens horribly, almost unrealistically. It is not suitable for precise application or blending at all. Layering it is like rolling pieces of plasticine together. It should not be applied to the mucous membrane either, as it stings. When I bought it, there were more negative reviews than positive ones, but I took a risk because of its waterproof feature. That's basically the only good thing about it, but it also became a downside because removing this mess is difficult. Maybe they have improved it now, or as it often happens, it depends on the color, but I definitely won't buy it again.

This is an incredible pencil! I buy the 12 shade to achieve a more natural makeup look, without it being too bright. It stays on in any weather, I just haven't tried it in the sauna. It doesn't smudge during summer or when I'm doing sports or in windy conditions. The quality is superb. HOWEVER, the downside is that it runs out very quickly. Because of its texture, it only lasts about 10 days with daily use.

I recommend size 20, it's a beautiful shade.

Great pencil. It applies easily and lasts for a whole day. I have three: green, brown, and gray, and I still want to get 21 more, but they are currently out of stock. I needed a good quality sharpener, so I ordered one from Makeupi.

This pencil is awesome. It glides on easily and stays put. It looks cool.

Awful pencil. It draws poorly, smudges even worse, and the lead constantly breaks. I bought it a while ago, but it's still almost intact and unused.

This pencil is very bad. As soon as I applied it, my eyes started burning. It feels like it's actually burning my eyes. I strongly advise against it!!

Only a negative experience. The pencil is like clay, it can't be sharpened - it just melts. When I draw with it, it smears and the lead "disintegrates". I now keep it in the refrigerator, but it doesn't help much. Trying to wash it off is also a whole ordeal, panda eyes are guaranteed. Never again.

I didn't like the pencil, so I won't buy it again.

I have developed an allergy.

Wonderful pencil. Applies easily. Can be smudged a bit. Looks amazing with green eyes.

This pencil is excellent, I'm pleased with the result. It applies easily and lasts a long time without smudging.

The best pencil, just a little difficult to sharpen!

Artdeco always succeeds in accentuating the eyes and is even suitable for the inner corner. Artdeco is always of high quality.

I absolutely love these pencils, and this is not the first time I have purchased them. Currently, I have the 11 and 15 colors! With a good sharpener, you can sharpen them to a nice point. They hold up really well and are just soft enough. I simply cannot imagine my morning without them!

The best waterproof pencil! My shade is Deep Brown.

The pencil was disappointing. It cannot be sharpened. It also fails to draw a clear line. It crumbles, scratches the eyelid, and even after sharpening, it no longer draws. It was a waste of money. I do not recommend it.

I really liked the pencil. It doesn't smudge on the eyes, it's easy to apply, and has a rich color. The only downside is that it's very difficult to sharpen, the tip constantly breaks. It would have been better if it were mechanical.

I have been using this pencil for many years and I really like it.

I purchased shade 15. It is a dark walnut color with a subtle shimmer. It is suitable for brown eyes and nude makeup.
I liked the color, the quality, the application on the eyelids, and the lasting power.
Thank you, make up, for your work during this challenging time. Peace and prosperity.

I purchased pencil 63. The color is a dark gray-green. It is a bit hard for my eyelids. It is not suitable for those who like to completely draw a thick line on top. However, if you only want to use it for the lower lid and for side lines, it is okay. Personally, I prefer the Colistar pencil more.

I ordered number 22, and I really liked the color (dark gray-green). I didn't expect it to have shimmer, but it looks amazing! I've never had such a long-lasting pencil before, it doesn't smudge at all throughout the day! I will definitely order more!

The pencil is long-lasting and soft, easily removed with micellar water. It has exceeded all expectations with a perfect score of 5+.

Pencil 12 Deep Brown - my love! It does not transfer onto the upper eyelid, does not smudge, is waterproof, and has a dark brown, almost black color with a subtle shimmer that is barely noticeable.

I am very disappointed because these pencils are not long-lasting at all. Why are there so many positive reviews? I bought three of them right away for my eyeliner (11, 20, 85). The eyeliner stays on until lunchtime, after which the tips disappear completely. The rest easily washes off with micellar water, but if desired, it can also be removed with a dry cotton swab. I used Essence pencils (twice as cheap) for several years, and the eyeliner would stay on until night. But now they are not available for sale. I don't know what to replace them with...

I don't share the general enthusiasm for this product. The pencil creates uneven lines and it's impossible to apply the shadow properly. Moreover, it runs out quickly, adding to the overall disappointment.

The shade "63" (green) is long-lasting and doesn't smudge. I have hooded eyelids, so I am very satisfied. I am confident that each shade can be applied differently and may have varying qualities.

For its price, this pencil is decent. However, I have a question: is it a counterfeit or not? Because in other stores, the minimum price for an ArtDeco brand pencil is 250-280 UAH.
If you don't expect much from it and just need the basics, it will do the job. But no, I would recommend looking for other options.
Firstly, the cap doesn't fit securely onto the bottom.
Secondly, when removing it with micellar water, it comes off in clumps and can be quite frustrating.
Thirdly, I suggest purchasing a very high-quality and sharp sharpener right away. Because you won't be able to sharpen it with a knife or anything else. You'll just end up losing your nerves.

The pencil is absolutely not long-lasting, it's a shame I fell for the reviews below!!! After an hour, it's gone from the lower eyelid (not on the mucous membrane), and the line on the upper lid smudges after an hour too. How can we talk about longevity if it immediately smudges off with a finger? The shade 12 - Deep Brown looks like black. I am attaching screenshots and videos where you can see that the pencil smudges with a light touch of a finger. I have no complaints about the makeup itself.

This pencil is excellent! It glides on smoothly. Whether it's intense heat, rain, or a melting snowflake, it doesn't fade or smudge. Wherever I apply it in the morning, it stays put until evening. And it easily washes off with a hydrophilic oil.

I have been using this pencil for several years now and I am extremely satisfied with it. I highly recommend it if you have chosen it as your preferred option.

#98 is the perfect shade of white for me. It is bright, long-lasting, and glides on smoothly and effortlessly. I've been searching for a pencil like this for the inner corners of my eyes for a long time, and I am extremely satisfied with this purchase.

Great pencil, I have ordered it twice and will continue to order it. It stays in place well, creates clear lines, and doesn't smudge. It's reasonably priced and of good quality.

Prints on the upper lid, I expected such low quality for this money.

The best pencil in its price range out of all the possible options. I can confidently say this as someone who uses waterproof pencils daily for over ten years, having tried numerous other pencils both cheaper and much more expensive, such as Chanel waterproof (which is significantly more expensive). Artdeco is simply the best and has no competitors. The most suitable shades for me are 11 and 12. These are dark brown shades, with 11 being slightly darker and 12 having a subtle shimmer.

Very easy to apply, it's a pleasure. However, it is not at all long-lasting on the mucous membrane.

It really stays on the mucous membrane throughout the day. A good product. Thank you, Makeup, for the delivery.

I give it 4 stars, but only for one reason - it cannot be removed even with micellar water. I thought my eyes would be swollen, but it was in vain. Then I applied some cream and it faded a bit.

I am extremely satisfied with this purchase! If anyone was looking for a pencil that is long-lasting on the mucous membrane and can also be used as a base for eyeshadows (i.e., easily blendable), then this is the exact pencil you need.

This is an excellent eyeliner pencil that makes drawing winged lines very convenient. The pencil is long-lasting, and the winged lines stay put for approximately 9-10 hours.

The quality of the pencil lead is excellent: it's soft and very durable, even on oily eyelids. However, due to its infamous softness, it cannot be sharpened in just two days, and a third of the pencil has worn down. Unfortunately, I won't be purchasing it again.

The pencil is simply amazing, I'm buying it for the second time. I really like it, as long as you have a decent sharpener, you won't have any problems. The eyeliner stays on well, but you need to remove it with special products.

I purchased it in shade 15. The color is interesting and looks good on pale skin, and it is long-lasting. The only thing that slightly surprised me is that I didn't expect it to be shiny. There are some noticeable large glitter particles. If you apply thick lines, it will have a shimmer effect.